Understanding the Unique Challenges for Ohio’s LGBTQ+ Community: Introduction (LGBT Blog Series Part 1)
Estate planning, while not glamorous, is essential for everyone, as it allows individuals to specify how they want their assets distributed, who will make medical decisions on their behalf, and who will care for their minor children if they pass away. However, for members of the LGBTQ+ community in Ohio, estate planning holds even more importance. Despite the progress made in recent years, many legal and social challenges remain that can complicate the estate planning process for LGBTQ+ individuals and couples. And now, more than ever, the legal landscape for members of this community is once again uncertain due to the current political climate in our country and our state.
Historically, Ohio’s legal system did not recognize same-sex relationships, limiting LGBTQ+ people’s ability to make legally binding decisions about their partners and children. While the landmark U.S. Supreme Court case Obergefell v. Hodges (2015) ensured marriage equality across the United States, and thus in Ohio, LGBTQ+ people continue to face unique issues in estate planning, family law, adoptions, name changes, etc. Many LGBTQ+ Ohioans who do not choose to marry or who face estrangement from their families may still encounter legal barriers when ensuring their assets go to their chosen beneficiaries or when arranging for healthcare and guardianship decisions, not to mention the issues surrounding custody and adoption that can arise.
This article aims to guide LGBTQ+ individuals in Ohio through these complexities by covering critical aspects of estate planning, including legal recognition of relationships, the importance of wills and trusts, healthcare directives, and parental rights. By the end, you’ll better understand Ohio's estate planning statutes and case law as they relate to LGBTQ+ people, helping you make informed decisions to secure you and your loved ones' futures.
The Importance of Estate Planning for LGBTQ+ Individuals
Why Estate Planning Is Critical
Estate planning allows individuals to protect their assets and ensure their wishes are respected upon incapacity or death. For LGBTQ+ people, clear estate planning is especially important for these reasons:
List of Services
-
Asset DistributionList Item 1
Without a legally recognized plan, an LGBTQ+ individual’s assets may be distributed according to Ohio’s intestacy laws (O.R.C. §2105.06), which may default to biological family members. This can pose a significant issue for LGBTQ+ individuals who wish to leave their assets to their partners, friends, or chosen family.
-
Healthcare DecisionsList Item 2
In the absence of clear directives, healthcare decisions may default to biological family members. Many LGBTQ+ individuals are estranged from their families, making it essential to assign medical decision-making rights to trusted individuals.
-
Guardianship of ChildrenList Item 3
LGBTQ+ parents, particularly non-biological parents, must ensure they have a legal plan in place to protect the custodial and guardianship rights of their children. Without clear documentation, surviving non-biological parents may face challenges if there is a dispute over guardianship rights.
Challenges for LGBTQ+ People Without Legal Protections
While the legalization of same-sex marriage has resolved some issues for LGBTQ+ couples, estate planning challenges persist for those who do not wish to marry or those in non-traditional family structures. Ohio’s intestacy laws prioritize biological relatives when distributing assets for individuals who pass away without a will, which may conflict with the wishes of LGBTQ+ individuals who want to leave assets to a partner or friend. For example, without a will, the estate may automatically pass to the deceased person’s parents, siblings, or other biological relatives, potentially excluding a same-sex partner or close friends from receiving any inheritance.
For LGBTQ+ individuals who are estranged from their families, this can be especially concerning. If estranged family members have priority by law, they may end up receiving the deceased’s assets despite the individual’s intent to benefit their partner or chosen family members. Comprehensive estate planning allows LGBTQ+ individuals to avoid these default rules, ensuring their wishes are documented and legally binding.
In the following sections, we’ll explore various elements of estate planning and offer guidance specific to LGBTQ+ individuals navigating Ohio's legal system. From creating legally valid wills to establishing trusts and healthcare directives, proper planning is essential for ensuring that LGBTQ+ people can protect their assets, secure healthcare rights, and care for their loved ones.
Legal Recognition of Relationships in Ohio
Marriage Equality’s Impact
The Obergefell v. Hodges (576 U.S. 644, 2015) decision was a landmark ruling that guaranteed marriage equality nationwide, granting same-sex couples the same legal rights and protections afforded to heterosexual married couples. In Ohio, this meant that LGBTQ+ couples could marry, thereby accessing spousal benefits previously reserved only for heterosexual couples. These benefits include automatic inheritance rights, spousal exemptions in estate taxes, and priority in making medical decisions for incapacitated spouses.
Under Ohio law, marriage is now formally recognized by O.R.C. §3101.01, which, following Obergefell, no longer discriminates based on the gender of the parties involved. This statute change has been critical for same-sex couples who, prior to Obergefell, could not rely on Ohio’s intestate succession laws, spousal rights in medical decisions, or family-based inheritance rights. Today, a married LGBTQ+ spouse in Ohio has legal priority in receiving assets if their partner dies without a will, and they have the authority to make critical health care decisions in emergency situations.
However, there is growing concern within the LGBTQ+ community regarding the stability of the Obergefell decision. If Obergefell were to be overturned, the implications for estate planning and legal rights for LGBTQ+ couples would be profound, particularly in states like Ohio that previously did not recognize same-sex marriages.
What Would Happen If Obergefell Were Overturned?
If Obergefell were overturned, Ohio would not be required to recognize same-sex marriages, as there is no Ohio statute that independently protects same-sex marriage outside the federal mandate established by Obergefell. This means that Ohio could revert to its pre-Obergefell laws, which banned same-sex marriage. Such a reversal would affect all areas of estate planning for LGBTQ+ individuals, as same-sex couples would lose the automatic rights and protections currently afforded to spouses. Key consequences could include:
1. Loss of Intestate Succession Rights:
If Obergefell were overturned, Ohio’s intestate succession laws (O.R.C. §2105.06) would likely no longer recognize same-sex spouses as legal heirs. This means that, absent a will, a deceased person’s assets would go to their biological relatives rather than a same-sex partner. LGBTQ+ individuals in Ohio would need to create explicit estate plans to protect their partner’s inheritance rights, as there would be no legal presumption of spousal inheritance.
2. Loss of Spousal Rights in Medical Decision-Making:
The right to make healthcare decisions for an incapacitated spouse is generally reserved for legal spouses. If Obergefell were overturned, same-sex partners could lose this right unless they have designated each other through a legally binding health care power of attorney. Without these designations, medical decision-making could default to biological family members, who may not support or respect the incapacitated partner’s wishes.
3. Potential Challenges to Parental Rights:
For LGBTQ+ couples with children, the loss of marriage recognition could complicate parental rights, especially for non-biological parents. In cases of incapacity or death, the non-biological parent may face custody challenges from biological relatives, and courts could potentially deny custody if the marriage were no longer recognized. Designating guardianship for minor children in estate planning documents would become even more essential.
4. Impact on Spousal Benefits and Taxes:
Married same-sex couples currently enjoy spousal exemptions in estate and inheritance taxes. If Obergefell were overturned, these couples would lose tax benefits, as Ohio and federal tax laws grant these exemptions only to legally recognized spouses. This would increase the tax burden on surviving LGBTQ+ partners, reducing the amount of assets that pass directly to them. Additionally, Social Security benefits and other spousal benefits may no longer be available to same-sex partners.
5. Increased Litigation and Estate Challenges:
The loss of marriage recognition would likely result in increased litigation over LGBTQ+ estates, especially in cases involving unsupportive biological family members. Without the automatic spousal protections provided under Obergefell, LGBTQ+ individuals would need to establish robust estate plans, including wills and trusts, to ensure their wishes are enforced without reliance on marital status.
Non-Marital Partnerships and Estate Planning
For LGBTQ+ individuals in committed relationships who have chosen not to marry, estate planning is even more essential. Ohio does not recognize common-law marriage for relationships formed after October 10, 1991 (O.R.C. §3105.12), so unmarried partners cannot rely on default inheritance rights or legal benefits typically available to married couples. This lack of recognition means that if one partner passes away without an estate plan, the surviving partner has no legal right to inherit the deceased’s assets or make medical or financial decisions on their behalf.
Intestate Succession and the Need for Explicit Documentation
Ohio’s intestacy laws follow a strict order of inheritance. In the absence of a will, assets pass first to the surviving spouse, then to descendants (children, grandchildren), followed by parents, siblings, and other next of kin (O.R.C. §2105.06). For unmarried LGBTQ+ partners, this means that a partner without legal status as a spouse is excluded from this hierarchy entirely. Consequently, any assets not specifically designated to the partner through a will or trust could be inherited by distant relatives, potentially bypassing the person whom the deceased most wanted to benefit.
Practical Steps for Members of the LGBTQ+ to Protect Their Estates
Ohio’s intestacy laws follow a strict order of inheritance. In the absence of a will, assets pass first to the surviving spouse, then to Given the potential threat to marriage equality, LGBTQ+ individuals in Ohio should consider taking proactive measures to protect their estates and relationships regardless of marital status:
List of Services
-
1. Execute a Will:List Item 1
Having a legally binding will is essential to specify who will inherit assets and assume guardianship responsibilities. Ohio requires that wills follow specific formalities to be valid, including being written, signed, and witnessed by two individuals (O.R.C. §2107.03). This clear documentation can help ensure that your partner inherits assets and that your wishes are legally enforceable.
-
2. Establish a Trust:List Item 2
A trust can serve as a powerful tool for asset management and inheritance, particularly for LGBTQ+ individuals who wish to provide for a partner without the need for probate. In Ohio, a revocable living trust allows individuals to transfer assets directly to a named beneficiary, bypassing probate and reducing the risk of a family contesting the inheritance. The privacy and control provided by trusts are especially beneficial for LGBTQ+ individuals who may not want their estate plans to be publicly contested or scrutinized.
-
3. Designating Beneficiaries on Financial Accounts:List Item 3
For accounts like life insurance policies, retirement plans, and bank accounts, LGBTQ+ individuals should designate their partners as beneficiaries to ensure direct inheritance. Beneficiary designations typically supersede instructions in a will, allowing for smoother asset transfer and providing additional protection for unmarried partners.
-
4. Use Powers of Attorney and Health Care Directives: Write a description for this list item and include information that will interest site visitors. For example, you may want to describe a team member's experience, what makes a product special, or a unique service that you offer.List Item 4
-
5. Review and Update Estate Plans Regularly:
In the face of legal uncertainties, LGBTQ+ individuals should review their estate plans frequently to ensure they reflect their current wishes and relationships.
By understanding Ohio’s probate process and tax rules, LGBTQ+ individuals can take proactive steps to minimize costs, expedite asset transfers, and reduce administrative burdens on their loved ones. Proper planning enables LGBTQ+ individuals to preserve their estate’s value, reduce family conflict, and honor their financial legacy.
Conclusion: Proactive Planning for LGBTQ+ Estate Security in Ohio
In Ohio, estate planning is essential for LGBTQ+ individuals to protect their assets, secure healthcare rights, and ensure their loved ones are cared for according to their wishes. Through comprehensive estate planning, LGBTQ+ Ohioans can address unique challenges in asset distribution, parental rights, healthcare directives, and protection from discrimination. Consulting an experienced estate planning attorney is crucial for navigating Ohio’s legal landscape and building a plan tailored to meet each individual’s needs and goals.
Share this post
